Frank Mizrahi and Michael Mugler: A Conversation
Father Michael Miyake Mugler (left) and Gary English (right) of P.O.C.C.photo by Ocean "Bernard" Morisset
Transient Communities, Cultural Work: Ballroom Culture and HIV/AIDS
Monday, March 6, 2006
People of Color in Crisis
Brooklyn, New York
7pm
Cultural historian Robin Kelley, in his brilliant essay "Looking to Get Paid: How Some Black Youth Put Culture To Work" attempts to theorize--by examining the historical and political contexts in which marginalized black youth engage in activities such as double-dutch, basketball, and dice-playing---the ways in which some racialized groups have used performance as a strategy for survival in their day to day life. Kelly's important notion of "performance" as a sort of cultural "work" is a useful approach to understanding the performance practices of my interviewee, Michael Roberson, the interviewed by director of prevention services at P.O.C.C. (People of Color in Crisis) and "Father" of the legendary House of Miyake Mugler.
In this interview Michael discusses his "work" in the underground ballroom scene, a transient black queer community that uses performance to critique the institutions of black belonging to which they have often been excluded. Describing the rich taxonomy of genders and sexualities at work in the ballroom scene, he discusses how he "fuses" his role as an activist and house father to intervene in the black cultural politics of HIV/AIDS.
What follows is only a very brief excerpt from the interview.
MR: The ballroom scene is an underground black and Latino, gay, lesbian, bisexual, transgender and sometimes questioning community. It’s a community that comes together to participate at “balls”—and I’ll describe what balls are in a second—to engage in battles for cash, trophies, or awards. But its truly much more than this. The categories include things like “runway”, or “vogue” (which is a type of dance) or aesthetic categories like “face”, “body”, and “sex siren.”
Now the whole scene, the houses, the balls, etc. can be likened to the Olympics. In the Olympics you have different countries coming together to compete for various categories which are judged by judges from countries representing those competing. The balls are the same. Different houses—like countries—come to the “ball” to compete and they are judged by individuals who are representative of the houses in the scene.
The house infrastructure is very similar to a family. So you have “Mothers”, “Fathers” and "children". Now of course a lot of this comes from people feeling like they’ve be ostracized from families because they're gay as well as from the larger black gay and lesbian community because of classism.
Now in actuality the ballroom scene is a social network because here we have a community that is not based on geography but instead on an infrastructure. So the same community that exists in New York is the same community that exist in Miami, so it’s a very transient community.
Most of this started out in New York City and it traveled to Washington D.C. by about 1987/1988. By 1989 it moved to Philadelphia. In fact Philly had its first ball in 1989, the “Onyx Ball.” Today the ballroom scene flows from as far off as Boston, down to Miami, it’s in Los Angeles and Oakland, it is the midwest in Chicago, Detroit, it’s gigantic in Atlanta, it’s in some of the Carolinas. So the community is quite large now and is quite transient.
FLR: So what does being in a house entail? For instance, describe your role as Father of the House of Miyake Mugler.
MR: Well being in a house entails membership very similar to being in a fraternity or sorority. Being in certain houses gives you different levels of prestige and/or power in the ballroom scene. You can be a part of the ballroom scene and walk balls and not be a part of a house, however this is just not the most effective way to participate in the scene. Especially if you’re looking to make a name for yourself. You need to be in a house.
Being in a house also entails being a part of a family. So many people feel like they don’t have an effective support system or family because they’re gay, and so the houses are reflective of that.
I just recently became Father of the New York City chapter of the House of Miyake-Mugler on July 30 of 2005. It was a honor for me because I take pride in my leadership abilities. One of the reasons I was asked to be Father is to revamp this house, particularly the New York Chapter, because it is where the House of Miyake Mugler began but it’s been null and void for some years now. So my role is really to rebuild and and reshape the house; to make it look very different. In the ballroom scene this house is known for “Face” and “Body” but I wanted to make it a more multifaceted to also be known for “Runway”, “Voguing”, etc.
In addition to that, the House of Miyake Mugler has traditionally been known for its men, what we call Butch Queens. Mugler has been known for men who have an everlasting presence in the ballroom scene. So my idea was and is to also let the house be known for its women, or what we call “Femme Queens.”
Most importantly, there are a lot of young people in the house and so the question for me as Father always becomes how you begin to help them develop their life skills. The ballroom scene, particulary the House of Mugler, is about this. I do prevention so Im interested in connecting my house to access to services. So that’s sort of how I see my role.
FLR: Now you mentioned “Butch Queens” and “Femme Queens”. Tell me a little bit about how people describe themselves in the ballroom scene. There is a truly rich taxonomy of genders and sexualities at play here. Describe a butch queen…
MR: [laughs] Ok, a Butch Queen is any man in the ballroom scene who is born biologically male and still presents himself as biologically male. That’s a butch queen. Now the reason I say “biologically male” is because [in the ballroom scene] we also have something called “butches.” Butches are individuals who were born biologically female but whose gender expression is male and so we call them butches. Butches can also be individuals who are born biologically female who are more aggressive or dominant in their mannerisms. These kinds of butches are not necessary interested in changing gender, just expressing it differently.
Femme Queens on the other hand are individuals who were born biologically male but whose gender expression, or transgender expression is female. And then we have Butch Queens Up in Drag which is gay men who go up in drag or cross dress for purposes only for the ballroom scene. Now some of this is kind of fluid because sometimes you will have folks who identify as Butch Queens Up in Drag in transition to changing their gender to being a Femme Queen or transgender female.
FLR: So then how would you describe the notion of “Trade”?
MR: “Trade” is [understood] differently generationally. When I was younger “trade” used to be a description of a heterosexual man who engaged in sexual practices with other men but lived a heterosexual lifestyle. He was not interested in romantically being involved with another man, so you know he didn’t necessarily exchange phone numbers of anything like that. So then over time “Trade” began to mean…[long pause]. Trade began to mean dick. You know, “he has big trade”; “he has a big penis,” etc. It was a way to describe penis. Then finally “Trade” began to mean those who exchange sex for money.
[laughs]Now today, some of the younger children believe “Trade” is those who go up in what I call “Thug Drag”. You know “Thug Drag” is when black gay men put on their timberlands and hats, and dress in urban and hip-hop attire and try to manifest very heterosexist and misgynoist kinds of mannerisms. So now they call this “trade” too.
FLR: Michael, describe your first experience walking a ball…
MR: Oh it was horrifying, it was terrifying, you know…
FLR: What’d you walk?
MR: Body
FLR: Oh ok.
MR: Yeah, I was very afraid…I got chopped. It was in Philadelphia. I got chopped. It was just really, really horrfying. But what it did not do was prevent me from wanting to continue to participate or to continue to compete. The energy behind me getting chopped actually motivated me. Now what do I mean by “getting chopped”? Getting chopped means that you’re disqualified from a category at a ball. It means that the judges doesn’t agree that you have exactly what the category is asking for.
FLR: So now describe your first experience winning a ball, what did that feel like?
MR: Like I accomplished something. Like I wanted to keep walking. Like I accomplished something, stuff like that...
FLR: So Michael, how to fuse your role as an activist and a ballroom kid—you work here at P.O.C.C. as the Director of HIV Prevention Services, you’re a long time prevention worker, activist and scholar in the field. What’s the relationship between your role as an activist and your work as the father of the House of Mugler?
MR: It’s interesting you should ask me that. I’m not a believer in compartmentalizing who I am. So I’m not an “activist”---I actively live. You understand what I mean? I’m a black gay man and so my living is naturally black, gay, and male. So the work I do at P.O.C.C is for black gay men. The work that I do in the house-ball community is also for black gay men. So that’s not to say that aren’t members of the community that aren’t black, gay, and male, but that’s how I view my role or contribution to this universe. So I believe that’s the work I was called to do.
And so, you see, there’s no “fusion” for me because there has never been a separation. So when I go out to a ball, I bring my full self with me. My full self is Father Miyake Mugler. My full self is Director of Services at P.O.C.C.. My full self is being the only male child is being the only male child of Mary Elizabeth Roberson. My full self is a lover of black men. So I am privileged to have the opportunity not to do distinguish between roles.
I remember someone once asking the question “because Michael is the Father of the house of Miyake Mugler, does that mean that the house is going to benefit financially from the services at P.O.C.C” And my response was absolutely yes, because Father Michael Miyake Mugler is also director of services at P.O.C.C and there is no separation between these two identities.
So when we have preventions activities here at P.O.C.C. it’s important for me to engage the members of my house to be a part of those services. Now vice versa, when we are doing things as a house or in the ballroom scene, it is important for me to engage employees here at P.O.C.C. in the activities we do as a ballroom community.
FLR: Tell me about what you see in your future here at P.O.C.C. both administratively and beyond. More broadly, what directions do you see your “work” taking? Along these same lines, what do you see in your ballroom future?
Well its all in one. I’m a believer that I don’t do “HIV prevention work” I do black gay men’s work, HIV just happens to be one thing that impacts black gay men.
FLR: Ah, I see. So you’re a cultural worker.
MR: Interesting you should say that. I would like to believe that’s what I am, yes. I gather that one of my ambitions is to write about the experiences of black gay men in this community. I have a desire to get into a Ph.D. program for Cultural Anthropology. I say that to say that my ambitions are broad. So from a small mama and pop shop-agency to a nationally recognized black agency, the biggest in regards to budget and programming actually.
FLR: And it’s New York City’s only black gay men’s agency, no?
MR: No, it’s one out of two indenginous black gay agency’s in New York City with G.M.A.D. (Gay Men of African Descent) being the first the whole country. P.O.C.C was founded in ’88 and GMAD in 1986.
FLR: OK
MR:
So in terms of my leadership within the ballroom scene, I’m invested in mobilizing our community to begin to build economic and political infrastructure within a black gay context that doesn’t have to exist in the space of second class status. I’m tired of us [the ballroom scene] not benefiting from some of the struggles of black leadership or black politics, even black gay leadership or black gay politics.
I also believe there is so much richness within the house-ball community, I think to do some true anthropological research from the lens of a participant would be very new and rich. I see myself at P.O.C.C being able to do that work.
With P.O.C.C. I also want to do something that is often lost in HIV prevention worker among CBO’s [community based organizations]. That is to have a black CBO that also has a research arm; a think tank connected with it. We need to begin to think about he can start to ask appropriate research questions about black gay men’s lives that go far beyond HIV. We [leadership at P.O.C.C.] have learned to stop self defining and self-determining black gay men solely around this disease that was meant to kill us.
Because the ambivalence is this: the monster that was meant to kill us has also given us so much life. This infection that was meant to kill us have given us political and economic life. HIV/AIDS has become an industry that people work within now. There are jobs. People are out now. So even while someone like James Baldwin existed within an “invisible” context before HIV/AIDS, people like Keith Boykin can now be politically and economically successful specifically because of this virus. So you see, what I’m saying is, this issue that was meant to kill us has also given birth to all kinds of new life. I see my work as a house father and as a prevention worker to try facilitate this life.
Michael Roberson is the Director of Services at People of Color in Crisis (POCC). A co-founder of the House of Manolo-Blahnik, he is Father of the New York City chapter of the House of Miyake-Mugler. Contact him at Michael@pocc.org

What a wonderful interview and also very encouraging. I really like how Mr. Roberson sees himself and his ideas for the black gay community. I do wish more members of the ball scene knew that important figures within scene like Mr. Roberson--and yourself--are much more than a major force in a category. He's a major force in activism and the movement that is necessary for we as black gay men to truly see who we are. Great job.
Posted by
MatisseNdegeocello |
3/27/2006
Cool site on fat man Check out my How Do I Enlarge My Penis
Posted by
Anonymous |
5/02/2006
The Latex Ball
Our first time (the right place at the wrong time)!
Stop the show!
What if the cure was the sickness?
I mean, their propaganda is really offensive to me as a human being. I'm not an object, a piece of latex to be used and thrown in the toilet. I am made of "flesh and bones". Not everybody is a latex!
What's all this spectacular glorification of consumerism about?
Discrimination is that you can't perform if you are not part of a "house", inside a four walls institution, just like jail.
Creating discrimination is having a VIP area.
No wonder why we can't still share the bathrooms.
Creative vision or imprisonning mission?
Sex, drugs and aids perversion...
Bringing the past to the present.
Sixteen plus years and getting sicker! Hope we don't have more of the same next year, maybe less HIV, more sexual freedom and less houses!
It seems that we must make war on everything an forget about love. And that we must choose from only two things among the infinite things that exist. Yes, some people call that freedom and using the brain? So, listen to your heart, use your brain not a condom! Think! We are all in the same orgy not fight!
So, we wanted to celebrate and share our sensuality and ideas, not to be better or worse than others, sell our bodies or compete and fight (which creates the same).
We were told that anyone could participate, but when we got there they told us we couldn't, that we needed to be part of something called a house. Well, it was really confusing. At the end we were glad because anyhow we didn't wanted to be part of that show, propaganda, house or fraternity. What we do is based on our lifes, it is real and trully original! Yes, we could have won in all categories. Anyone can! We don't get our clothes from fashion stores nor our ideas from the screen. We are the fetish and take our share of S&M on the streets, not like the rich.
Why are we always being judged (by them). Who are they or us anyway? I don't like judges in court, why would I like them at the dance floor or board-walk?
Talking about discrimination again, it seems that among the slaves, ourselves or them/us you can use derogatory words and mock your brothers and sisters. You can call them bitches, sluts, niggers, dirty, stinky, fat, etc. That's confusing and create division on the outside or real world. But of course they will take care of you and change you, just like that movie "1984", you will look "whiter". Whatever happened to tollerance, diversity and the like.
NBC Universal was watching you. They were taking pictures of you and me, targets for their new propaganda and mind manipulation!
If you keep telling the people they have aids or are at risk they will start to believe it and be part of that reality. The mind is a powerful thing, don't let no one control your prayers/will.
Did they talk you about love and caring or only about fucking and sucking? Did they teach you that you can be really free or only told you that you are at risk?
You are not at risk (maybe only if you use all there toys as directed and in order), you are being manipulated, lied and experimented on.
I almost believed!
Fortunately it came to my mind that I know better... Just like in the movie "raiders of the lost ark", at the end, only those who looked died. Just like that city in the bible that was destroyed, don't look back, don't believe, don't listen to their propaganda, it kind of hipnotize you! It looked also like one of those stories narrated in history books about the selling of slaves... do you have good teeth or what it takes? It also remind me of that movie, "the fifth element" and the show world, where ignorance was bliss and nobody knew what was really going on in the world. But sure anyone could die.
Thou, a fight broke out just behind us, and their god only knows why. And no one really told you about those seven newark girls, but there was a price for a butch face. And if the song about a barbie girl was not enough to make us finally bored and leave, we get to see the dying birds...
The future in not silver! It is nature, nakedness, healing, and not more garbage and sickness, that fear that gets the economy alive and the people dying. Fancy shitty impersonal propaganda. Just like a drug it/they fuck/s with your mind.
When are you going to trascend the genders, because gay or lesbian you are still stocked in roles and under the gun.
Test yourself and get your H&M gift card. Do not create or think, just go out, choose and buy!
Now that the emperor is wearing no clothes, what dress will you wear?
Life must go on!
Posted by
Anonymous |
8/29/2007
Erectile dysfunction is the inability to attain or maintain an adequate penile erection to penetrate the vagina during sexual intercourse. Some experts feel that the onset of erectile dysfunction causes some men to become depressed while others seem to think that depression is the primary cause of erectile dysfunction. http://www.levitrabliss.com/
Posted by
Anonymous |
10/08/2008
All information about erectile dysfunction available here http://www.starpills.com
For more information about weekend pill cialis find you here http://www.impotencehealthcenter.com If you want to try best ed pill in europe
try this site http://www.levitraportal.com
ViagraLevitra couponCialis a day
Posted by
Bill12 |
5/03/2009
Charleston turned a pair of double plays to do the trick. The spyder jackets had at least one runner on in every inning but the first and outhit the RiverDogs by a 12-6 margin cheap columbia jackets.Lawal should be a focal point of the Yellow cheap polo shirts along with highly touted newcomer, 6-9 Derrick Favors, rated as the No. 1 power forward on the ESPNU 100. The Yellow Jackets
PayPal Payment. Enjoy your shopping experience on mensclothingstore.Usnike max shoes, one of the world's three major brands of Puma shoes, will build its factory in Lanshan county next year, Hunan province. Taiwan Diamond Group of Footwear production chooses its base in Lanshan county, which is one of top 500 companies in the world.
Posted by
Anonymous |
6/17/2009
[url=http://forums.bleachexile.com/member.php?u=57438]digital camera to [/url] and
[url=http://forums.bleachexile.com/member.php?u=57532]hip pain
knee pain
chest pain
chronic pain
back pain
[/url]
[url=http://kinopoisk.sms-jet.ru/sitemap.html]скачать фильмы[/url] скачать фильмы
digital camera 12 and
back pain treatment
hip pain
leg pain
joint pain
chest pain
Posted by
Anonymous |
12/12/2009
The erection problem is termed as one of the most dangerous problems in a person’s life. If you suffer from this problem you will face some pain while erection and moreover you might also not be able to lead a happy sexual life.
Generic Viagra
Posted by
Anonymous |
12/25/2009
The erection problem is termed as one of the most dangerous problems in a person’s life. If you suffer from this problem you will face some pain while erection and moreover you might also not be able to lead a happy sexual life.
Generic Viagra
Posted by
Anonymous |
12/25/2009
[url=http://satrise.ru/familiya/sitemap_0.html]происхождение фамилии[/url]
а также
[url=http://satrise.ru/]значение фамилии[/url]
а также
[url=http://znacheniie.ru/]происхождение фамилии[/url]
а также
[url=http://znacheniie.ru/sitemap_0.html]значение фамилии[/url]
мои сайты для вас
значение фамилии
а также
значение фамилии
а также
значение фамилии
а также
происхождение фамилии
а также
Посмотреть фильм онлайн бесплатно
[url=http://nasharussia3.rv.ua/]смотреть онлайн Наша раша Яйца судьбы [/url]
смотреть онлайн Наша раша Яйца судьбы
Посмотреть фильм онлайн бесплатно
Мне бы в небо фильм предварительная продажа билетов а также смотрите кинопремьера скоро
[url=http://nasharushakino.rv.ua/]смотреть онлайн Наша раша Яйца судьбы[/url]
скачать фильм Наша раша Яйца судьбы
Посмотреть фильм онлайн бесплатно вместе с семьей
Samsung lcd
Posted by
Anonymous |
1/19/2010